Using $t$-distribution for Robust ‎Hierarchical Bayesian Small Area Estimation under Measurement Error in Covariates

Authors

  • Shaho Zarei Department of Statistics, Faculty of Science, University of Kurdistan
  • Serena Arima Department of History, Social Science and Human Studies, University of Salento, Lecce, Italy.

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.1285/i20705948v16n3p722

Keywords:

‎Small area estimation‎, MCMC methods, ‎Area-level model‎, ‎Measurement error‎, ‎Hierarchical Bayesian modelling.‎

Abstract

Small area estimation often suffers from imprecise direct estimators due to small sample sizes. One method for giving direct estimators more strength is to use models.‎ Models ‎employ area effects and ‎include supplementary information  from extra sources as covariates to increase the accuracy of direct estimators. ‎The valid covariates are the basis of ‎the ‎small ‎area ‎estimation.‎ Therefore, measurement error (ME) in covariates can produce contradictory results, i.e., even reduce the precision of direct estimators. The Gaussian distribution with known variance is generally apply as a distribution of ME. ‏‎ ‎However‎, ‎in real problem, ‎‎there might be situations in which the normality assumption fo MEs does not hold‎. In addition, the assumption of known ME variance is restricted. To address these issues and obtain a more robust model, ‎‎we propose modeling ME using a $t$-distribution with known and unknown degrees of freedom. Model parameters are estimated using a fully Bayesian framework based on MCMC methods. We validate our proposed model using simulated data and apply it to well-known crop data and the cost and income of households living in Kurdistan province of ‎Iran.‎

References

begin{thebibliography}{}‎

‎bibitem[Arima {em et~al.}(2015)]{Arima:Datta:Liseo:2015}‎

‎Arima‎, ‎S.‎, ‎Datta‎, ‎G.S‎. ‎and Liseo‎, ‎B‎. ‎(2015)‎. ‎Bayesian estimators for small area models when auxiliary information is measured with error‎.

‎{em Scandinavian Journal of Statistics}‎, ‎{bf 42}(2)‎, ‎518--529‎.

‎bibitem[Akinc and Vandebroek (2018)]{Akinc:Vandebroek:2018}‎

‎Akinc‎, ‎D‎. ‎and Vandebroek‎, ‎M‎. ‎(2018)‎. ‎Bayesian estimation of mixed logit models‎: ‎Selecting an appropriate prior for the covariance matrix‎.

‎{em Journal of choice modelling}‎, ‎{bf 29}‎, ‎133--151‎.

‎bibitem[Battese {em et~al.} (1998)]{Battese:Harter:Fuller:1998}‎

‎Battese‎, ‎G.E.‎, ‎Harter‎, ‎R.M‎. ‎and Fuller‎, ‎W.A‎. ‎(1988)‎. ‎An error components model for prediction of county crop areas using survey and satellite data‎.

‎{em Journal of the American Statistical Association}‎, ‎{bf 83}‎, ‎28--36‎.

‎bibitem[Bell and Huang (2006)]{Bell:Huang:2006}‎

‎Bell‎, ‎W.R‎. ‎and Huang‎, ‎E.T‎. ‎(2006)‎. ‎Using the $t$-distribution to deal with outliers in small area estimation‎.

‎{em In Proceedings of Statistics Canada Symposium.}‎

‎bibitem[Chakraborty {em et~al.} (2017)]{Chakraborty:Datta:Mandal:2017}‎

‎Chakraborty‎, ‎A.‎, ‎Datta‎, ‎G.S‎. ‎and Mandal‎, ‎A‎. ‎(1988)‎. ‎Robust hierarchical Bayes small area estimation for nested error regression model‎.

‎{em arXiv preprint arXiv:1702.05832.}‎

‎bibitem[Fay and Herriot (1979)]{Fay:Herriot:1979}‎

‎Fay‎, ‎M.P‎. ‎and Herriot‎, ‎R.A‎. ‎(1979)‎. ‎Estimates of income for small places‎: ‎an application of‎

‎James-Stein procedures to census data‎.

‎{em Journal of the American Statistical Association}‎, ‎{bf 74}(366a)‎, ‎269--277‎.

‎bibitem[Ghosh {em et~al.}(2018)]{Ghosh:Myung:Moura:2018}‎

Ghosh, M., Myung, J. and Moura, F. A. (2018). Robust Bayesian small area estimation.

‎{em Survey Methodology}‎, ‎{bf 44}(1)‎, 101--116‎.

‎‎

‎bibitem[Goo and Kim (2013)]{Goo:Kim:2013}‎

‎Goo‎, ‎Y.M‎. ‎and Kim‎, ‎D.H‎. ‎(2013)‎. ‎Bayesian small area estimations with measurement errors‎.

‎{em Journal of the Korean Data $&$ Information Science Society}‎, ‎{bf 24}(4)‎, ‎885--895‎.

bibitem[Hariyanto {em et~al.}(2020)]{Hariyanto:Notodiputro:Kurnia:Sadik:2020}‎

Hariyanto, S., Notodiputro, K. A., Kurnia, A. and Sadik (2020). Small Area Estimation with Measurement Error in t Distributed Covariate Variable.‎

‎{em International Journal of Advanced Science and Technology}‎, ‎{bf 10}(4)‎, 1536--1542‎.‎

‎bibitem[Molina and Rao (2015)]{MolinaRao:2015}‎

‎Molina‎, ‎I‎. ‎and J.C‎. ‎Rao (2015)‎.

‎newblock {em {Small Area Estimation}}‎.

‎newblock John Wiley $&$ Sons‎.

‎bibitem[Sinha and Rao (2009)]{Sinha:Rao:2009}‎

‎Sinha‎, ‎S.K‎. ‎and Rao‎, ‎J.N.K‎. ‎(2009)‎. ‎Robust small area estimation‎.

‎newblock {em Canadian Journal of Statistics}‎ , ‎{bf 37}(3)‎, ‎381--399‎.

‎bibitem[Spiegelhalter {em et~al.}(2002)]{Spiegelhalter:Best:Carlin:Van:2002}‎

‎Spiegelhalter‎, ‎D.J.‎, ‎Best‎, ‎N.G.‎, ‎Carlin‎, ‎B.P‎. ‎and Van Der Linde‎, ‎A‎. ‎(2002)‎. ‎Bayesian measures of model complexity and fit‎.

‎{em Journal of the Royal Statistical Society‎: ‎Series B‎

‎(Statistical Methodology)}‎, ‎{bf 64}(4)‎, ‎583--639‎.

bibitem[You and Chapman (2006)]{You:Chapman:2006}‎

You, ‎Y‎. ‎and Chapman‎, ‎B‎. ‎(2006)‎. ‎Small area estimation using area-level models and estimated sampling variances‎.

‎{em Survey Methodology}‎, ‎{bf 1}(32)‎, ‎97--103‎.

‎bibitem[Ybarra and Lohr (2008)]{Ybarra:Lohr:2008}‎

‎Ybarra‎, ‎L.M‎. ‎and Lohr‎, ‎S.L‎. ‎(2008)‎. ‎Small area estimation when auxiliary information is measured with error‎.

‎{em Biometrika}‎, ‎{bf 95}(4)‎, ‎919--931‎.

‎bibitem[Zarei {em et~al.}(2021)]{shaho:serena:Giovanna2020}‎

‎Zarei‎, ‎S‎. ‎and Arima‎, ‎S‎. ‎and Giovanna‎, ‎J.L‎. ‎(2021)‎. ‎A new robust Bayesian small area estimation via $a$-stable model for estimating the proportion of athletic students in California‎.

‎{em Biometrical Journal}‎, ‎{bf 63}(6)‎, ‎1309--1324‎

‎end{thebibliography}‎

Downloads

Published

15-12-2023